Notes
Slide Show
Outline
1
Revised estimates of lifetime Net Merit for dairy breeds and breed crosses
2
Introduction
  • Previous estimates used net merit (NM$), cheese merit (CM$), and fluid merit (FM$) formulas from 2000
  • Dairy breeds and breed crosses were compared using updated NM$, CM$, and FM$ formulas that include daughter pregnancy rate (DPR), calving ease, and stillbirth


3
Data and Methods
  • National data for milk, fat, protein, productive life, SCS, and DPR were each evaluated using an all-breed animal model
  • New estimates of breed differences were compared to phenotypic breed differences and to previous estimates from studies that only included herds containing crossbred cows


4
Breed Effects and Heterosis
  • New estimates of breed differences were generally intermediate between the previous estimates and the phenotypic breed differences; all three estimates were similar
  • Estimates of general heterosis from previous studies were used in the current research and not re-estimated
5
Breed Effects and Heterosis
Transmitting ability differences from Holstein
6
Other Trait Estimates
  • Body size composite estimated from mature weight
  • Udder composite, Feet & Leg composite extrapolated from regressions on other traits within Holsteins
    • Size, PL, milk, DPR, SCS
  • Breed means for calving ease and for stillbirth
    • 7.3 million HO, 37000 JE, 17000 BS,       2000 GU, 2000 AY, 300 MS
7
Trait Correlations within Holsteins
(and Jersey correlations for comparison)
8
Assumed Effects – Other Traits
Transmitting ability differences from Holstein
9
Net Merit Relative Emphasis
10
NM$, FM$, CM$ - Economic Values
11
Merit of F1 Holstein Crossbreds
12
Later Generation Crosses
13
“Exotic” Breeds
  • US has pedigree records for other breeds;  but very little production data
  • For further information:
    • Interbull conversions to Ayrshire base
    • U. Minnesota scientists (Heins et al.)
14
Conclusions
  • Breed effects were re-estimated
    • Yield, PL, SCS, DPR by all-breed model
    • Udder, F&L composites from other traits
    • Calving ease and stillbirth breed means
  • New Net Merit formula for August 2006
  • Holsteins still superior for FM$
15
Conclusions
  • HO x BS and HO x JE higher for NM$ and CM$
  • BS x JE higher than HO for CM$
  • Three breed crosses (HO, BS, JE) are higher than HO backcrosses for CM$, similar for NM$